Community

Blog

Articles on acupuncture, Chinese medicine and everyday wellbeing, arranged by topic, with the studies behind them.

Opinion pieceLast reviewed

The writer’s own view. It is not a summary of the research.

Why Aren’t You Needling Where It Hurts?

Why I often choose acupuncture points away from where it hurts, what the classics say about this approach, and what the research can tell us.

Reviewed by Sau Wan Fast, DAcHM, L.Ac., Dipl.Ac., Dipl.OM
6–9 minutes

“Wait, my neck hurts. Why are you putting a needle in my hand?”

I get this question all the time. It’s a fair one. If the left side of your neck has been stiff all week, you probably expect me to put a needle right there. But in the approach I was taught, I usually look somewhere else first. For pain on one side, that often means checking a point on the opposite side. I might press a spot on your right hand and ask, “Is this one sore?” Then I’ll ask you to turn your head again.

Where it hurts tells me what we need to look at. Where I put the first needle depends on what I find when I look.

Treating the opposite side goes back to the classics

The Yellow Emperor’s Inner Classic, a foundational Chinese medicine text, describes choosing points on the right for a problem on the left, and the other way around. [1] Another chapter gives an example of treating at a distance: choosing points on the feet for certain problems in the head. [2] A later acupuncture verse describes both approaches. [3]

These are two related ideas. A distal point is away from where you feel the problem. An opposite-side point is on the other side of your body. If the left side of your neck hurts and I choose a point on your right hand, that point is both. In my practice, I often look for both when treating one-sided pain. I start by seeing what movement bothers you, where you feel it, and which points respond when I press them.

In classical acupuncture, points are mapped along pathways called channels, or meridians. Knowing where those pathways run helps guide point selection. [4] For example, there’s a point on the little-finger side of the hand, known as SI 3, that’s traditionally used for neck stiffness. [5] It’s one possible point. Where you feel the pain and which movement brings it on help me decide whether it makes sense for you.

How I find a tender point

Some points are found by touch. I press gently and ask what you feel. The spot doesn’t have to be one of the named points on an acupuncture chart. The physician Sun Simiao described this way of finding points in his Essential Prescriptions Worth a Thousand Gold Pieces. [6] The Yellow Emperor’s Inner Classic also describes choosing spots that hurt when treating certain problems involving the body’s sinews. [7]

For pain on one side, I was taught to look for a tender spot away from where it hurts, often on the opposite side. You might have a sore left neck and have no idea a spot on your right hand is tender until I press it. When you say, “Oh, that one aches,” it gives me a point to consider. I still want to see whether using it changes the movement that brought you in. A spot can be tender without being useful for that particular treatment.

Has this been studied?

In a small study of 38 people with chronic pain in one shoulder, both groups received acupuncture at the same lower-leg point (ST 38). One group was treated on the same side as the painful shoulder; the other was treated on the opposite side. Both groups reported less pain immediately afterward, with a greater drop in the opposite-side group. The trial didn’t compare leg needling with shoulder needling or recruit specifically for frozen shoulder. [8]

In another small trial, 36 people with chronic neck pain had less pain with movement right after acupuncture at distant points than after local trigger-point dry needling or sham laser treatment. The trial compared different techniques, so it can’t tell us whether point location alone made the difference. Both studies measured immediate changes; they don’t tell us how long the relief lasts. [9]

Research suggests acupuncture may affect how the nervous system functions. How that translates into pain relief, or why a particular point may help in one case and make little difference in another, is still being studied. [10]

Why I take points on the hands and feet seriously

Our skin isn’t equally sensitive everywhere. Researchers estimated about 58 nerve fibers that carry touch signals per square centimeter in the palm, compared with 9 in the skin over the front of the torso. The toes also had a relatively high estimated density. [11] The fingertips were more densely supplied still, at about 241 per square centimeter. [12] That helps explain why small changes in touch can be easier to notice in these areas. It doesn’t tell us how much pain relief a needle there will give.

In my practice, I’ve consistently found distal points more efficient than working directly on the sore area. I’ve seen many patients improve with distal points alone, including people with frozen shoulder who could move their shoulder more easily after just one session. That’s what I’ve seen in clinic. Easier movement is definitely a meaningful first step, and full recovery from frozen shoulder still require more care. [13]

What changes for you?

I’ll ask you to try the movement that bothers you before and after I needle. Does your neck turn more easily? Can you reach a little higher? What you feel helps me decide whether to stay with that point or try another. At your next visit, I’ll ask whether it was still easier when you got home.

Does treating nearby also have a place in classical acupuncture?

Yes. The classical texts also describe choosing points at or near a tender spot. [6][7] At Fingertips, looking elsewhere first is a deliberate part of how I was trained. I can assess your neck closely and still decide that the best place to begin treatment is your hand.

If you’re on the table wondering why I’ve gone to your hand when you came in for your neck, please ask. I’m happy to tell you what I’m looking for. Often the easiest way to explain it is to have you try that movement again and tell me what you feel.

Common questions

Why are you pressing a spot that didn’t hurt before?+

I’m checking whether there’s a tender point I can use. For one-sided pain, I often check the opposite side. Your response to pressure helps me choose a point; how you move afterward helps me decide whether to keep using it.

If the pain changes right away, does that mean the problem is fixed?+

An immediate change is useful feedback. I still want to know whether the improvement holds up when you get back to the things that usually bother you.

References

  1. Huangdi Neijing, Su Wen, chapter 63: Discussion of Cross-Needling (繆刺論). Describes opposite-side point selection and distinguishes miu ci from ju ci.
  2. Huangdi Neijing, Ling Shu, chapter 9: Zhong Shi (終始). Gives examples of choosing points far from the problem.
  3. Biao You Fu (標幽賦), in Zhen Jiu Da Quan (針灸大全). Verse and commentary on opposite-side and distant point selection.
  4. Huangdi Neijing, Ling Shu, chapter 10: Channels (Jing Mai, 經脈). Describes the role of understanding the channels in acupuncture.
  5. eLotus CORE: Houxi (SI 3). Traditional point location and use for neck stiffness.
  6. Sun Simiao. Bei Ji Qian Jin Yao Fang, chapter on moxibustion methods (灸例第六). Describes locating Ashi points by pressure and patient response.
  7. Huangdi Neijing, Ling Shu, chapter 13: Sinew Channels (經筋). Describes choosing painful sites in certain sinew-channel treatments.
  8. Hu S, Zhang S, Shi G, et al. Immediate analgesia effect of contralateral needling at Tiaokou (ST38) in patients with chronic shoulder pain. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medical Sciences. 2019;6(1):95–100. Exploratory trial comparing opposite-side and same-side needling.
  9. [Irnich D, et al. Immediate effects of dry needling and acupuncture at distant points in chronic neck pain](https://doi.org/10.1016/S0304-3959(02)00062-3). Pain. 2002;99(1–2):83–89. Randomized crossover trial measuring immediate effects.
  10. National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health: Acupuncture—Effectiveness and Safety. Summarizes what is known about how acupuncture may work.
  11. Corniani G, Saal HP. Tactile innervation densities across the whole body. Journal of Neurophysiology. 2020;124(4):1229–1240. Table 1 estimates touch-sensitive nerve fiber density by body region.
  12. Johansson RS, Vallbo ÅB. Tactile sensibility in the human hand. Journal of Physiology. 1979;286:283–300. Estimates touch-sensitive nerve fiber density across the hand.
  13. American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons: Frozen Shoulder. Explains the symptoms and course of frozen shoulder.

Ready to talk about your own care? Book an appointment with Sau Wan Fast.

Book Now

Book a visit

Begin with a conversation.

Every course of care starts with listening. Request a time that suits you and we will be in touch to confirm.